Glycan Function Workshop at SfG 2023: Difference between revisions

From GlyGen Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(First draft of the page)
No edit summary
 
(43 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
The workshop on "Glycan Function Annotation" associated with the annual meeting of the Society for GlycoBiology 2023 will be held on November 4th at Hilton Waikoloa Village Resort, on the big island of Hawaii. The workshop is organized and chaired by Dr. Mike Tiemeyer and Dr. René Ranzinger from the [https://ccrc.uga.edu/ Complex Carbohydrate Research Center] and sponsored by the [https://www.glygen.org/ GlyGen project] with the support of NIH. This workshop follows the [[Glycan Function Workshop 2023|workshop on "Glycan Function"]] held in Padova, Italy in May 2023. While the workshop in Italy was pretty much focused on the bioinformatics and biocuration aspects of glycan function the workshop in Hawaii will focus on the biology and chemistry aspects.
The second "Workshop on Glycan Function Annotation," entitled "Defining Glycan Functions" will be held on November 4th at Hilton Waikoloa Village Resort in Kona on the big island of Hawaii, just prior to the 2023 annual meeting of the Society for GlycoBiology. The workshop is organized and chaired by Dr. Michael Tiemeyer and Dr. René Ranzinger from the [https://ccrc.uga.edu/ Complex Carbohydrate Research Center] and is sponsored by the [https://www.glygen.org/ GlyGen project] with the support of NIH. A select group of glycobiology experts have been invited to participate in discussions and contribute their ideas for developing a framework of terms and concepts relating glycan functions to glycan structural features, motifs, and patterns.


=== Organization Committee ===
=== Workshop Goals ===
Dr. Mike Tiemeyer and Dr. René Ranzinger organizing and chairing the workshop. Other people that helped in planning the agenda and organizing the meeting are:


* Raja Mazumder ([https://www.glygen.org/ GlyGen])
This workshop builds on the results of the first [[Glycan Function Workshop 2023|"Workshop on Glycan Function Annotation"]] which was held in Padova, Italy, May 2023 in association with this year’s annual International BioCuration meeting. The first workshop brought together interested developers and leaders of international bioinformatics platforms to discuss what kinds of glycoscience data were currently available or were desirable for sharing across platforms, leading to concrete suggestions for improving the visibility and impact of glycan, glycosylation, and glycoconjugate data.  
* Karina Martinez ([https://www.glygen.org/ GlyGen])
* Anna Bighta ([https://ccrc.uga.edu/ Complex Carbohydrate Research Center])


=== Venue ===
Among the recommendations of the first workshop was a proposal that the bioinformatics community would benefit from the organization of a second workshop that could harvest input from experts in glycan functions. It was anticipated that such experts could provide useful landmarks in the rapidly expanding terrain of functional glycobiology data that could guide the development of useful knowledgebases and cross-references across datatypes. With the collaborative input of data scientists, such landmarks could subsequently be developed into a glycan function ontology, similar to “GO” annotations for gene product functions. A glycan function ontology would provide a potentially powerful framework for connecting glycoscience data to many mainstream big data resources.  
'''Hilton Waikoloa Village'''


69-425 Waikoloa Beach Drive
'''''Expected deliverables from the upcoming Kona workshop include:'''''


Waikoloa, HI 96738
# Robust discussion and subsequent documentation that establishes some level of consensus on well-supported glycan functions.
# Discussion and documentation of potential hierarchical relationships between glycan functions.
# Discussion and documentation that connects functions to explicit glycan structures, structural motifs, features, or patterns whenever possible.
# Discussion and documentation that highlights where ambiguities exist in connecting glycan structures and functions.
# Discussion and documentation of proposals for annotating glycan functions that are independent of the carrier to which they are attached or are specific for the carrier and perhaps the site on the carrier to which they are attached (autonomous vs. non-autonomous functions).


=== Travel information ===
To provide structure for the workshop, five general areas of glycan function have been chosen for framing discussions.  However, the organizers expect that the boundaries of these areas are porous; we will proceed as best we can to achieve the goals. '''''We anticipate that a successful workshop will culminate in a shared-authorship manuscript which summarizes our deliberations for community consideration and comment.'''''
'''Airport'''


Kona International Airport (KOA) is a 20-minute (19 miles) car ride from the hotel.  
=== Venue ===
[[File:Conference Hotel.jpg|thumb|500px|Hilton Waikoloa Village]]
Queens Ballroom 4


'''Uber & Lyft'''                           
Hilton Waikoloa Village


Rides from Kona International Airport range from $21–$37.
69-425 Waikoloa Beach Drive


'''Taxi'''                                        
Waikoloa, HI 96738


Approx. $55-$65 (one way)
[[File:Queens 4 ballroom.jpg|thumb|500px|Floor plan with Queens 4 ballroom marked red.]]
'''Parking'''             
Self-Parking: $39/night
Valet Parking: $55/night


=== Schedule ===
=== Schedule ===
Line 40: Line 38:
!Presenters
!Presenters
!Reporters
!Reporters
!Group Members
|-
|-
|-
|-
|9:00
|9:00
|15 min
|10 min
|Welcome
|Welcome
|
|
|Raja Mazumder
|Mike Tiemeyer
 
 
Rene Ranzinger
Rene Ranzinger
|
|
|
|-
|-
|9:15
|9:10
|20 min
|20 min
|Glycan Function Overview
|Glycan Function Overview
|
|
|Mike Tiemeyer
|Mike Tiemeyer
|
|
|
|-
|-
|9:35
|9:30
 
|60 min  
9:55
|'''Adhesion and non-immune cell-cell interactions'''
|20 min
* 10 min introduction talk
 
* 10 min introduction talk
45 min
* 30 min open discussion
|Q1. How would your resource extract glycan related data from literature or other sources?
* 10 min session summary
 
|Mike Tiemeyer
 
|Lance Wells
Presentations
Ten Feizi
 
Discussions (All attendees)
|Hiren Joshi
|Yukie Akune
 
 
Kristian Axelsen
 
James Urban
|Rene Ranzinger
|Rene Ranzinger
 
Karina Martinez
 
Cecilia Arighi
|Vijay Shanker
|-
|-
|10:40
|10:30
|15 min
|15 min
|Coffee Break
| colspan="4" |Morning Coffee Break (in meeting room)
|
|
|
|
|-
|-
|10:55
|10:45
 
|60 min
11:15
|'''Modulation of immune and inflammatory responses'''
|20 min
 
45 min
|Q2. What type of glycan related data would be useful to your resource, that you don’t currently have access to?
 
 
Presentations
 
Discussions (All attendees)
|Maria Martin
|Randi Vita
 
 
Paul Thomas
 
Yan Liu
|Yasunori Yamamoto
 


* 10 min introduction talk
* 10 min introduction talk
* 30 min open discussion
* 10 min session summary
|Kiyoko Aoki-Kinoshita
|Jim Paulson
Rick Cummings
|Rene Ranzinger
Nathan Edwards
Nathan Edwards
|Emily Bordeleau
|-
|-
|12:00
|11:45
|50 min
| colspan="4" |Lunch (Kona Promenade)
|-
|12:35
|60 min
|60 min
|Lunch
|'''Modulation of signaling and protein function'''
|
* 10 min introduction talk
|
* 10 min introduction talk
|
* 30 min open discussion
|
* 10 min session summary
|Nathan Edwards
|Ron Schnaar
Karin Hoffmeister
|Rene Ranzinger
Kiyoko Aoki-Kinoshita
|-
|1:35
|60 min
|'''Protein folding and quality control'''
* 10 min introduction talk
* 10 min introduction talk
* 30 min open discussion
* 10 min session summary
|Lance Wells
|Hamed Jafar-Nejad
Nathan Edwards
|Rene Ranzinger
Mindy Porterfield
|-
|-
|1:00
|2:35
 
|15 min
1:20
| colspan="4" |Coffee Break (in meeting room)
|20 min
 
45 min
|Q3. What type of data, that you do have, might enhance glycan related data?
 
 
Presentations
 
Discussions (All attendees)
|Deepti Jaiswal Kundu
|Ted Groth
 
 
Ten Feizi
 
Kiyoko F. Aoki-Kinoshita
|Frederique Lisacek
 
 
Callum Ives
|Raja Mazumder
|-
|-
|2:05
|2:50
 
|60 min
 
|'''Other (structural, developmental, protection, probiotic, etc.)'''
2:25
* 10 min introduction talk
|20 min
* 10 min introduction talk
 
* 30 min open discussion
 
* 10 min session summary
45 min
|Marie Hollenhorst
|Q4. What standards does your resource use for the glycan related annotations?
|Hans H. Wandall
 
Shinobu Kitazume
 
|Rene Ranzinger
Presentations
Mike Tiemeyer
 
Discussions (All attendees)
|Mike Tiemeyer
|Adnan Malik
 
 
Kalpana Panneerselvam
 
Susan Bello
|Krishna Khakurel
 
 
Karina Martinez
|Taciana Manso
|-
|-
|3:10
|3:50
|50 min
|10 min
|Break out session: Chair, presenters, reporters and group members meet with their designated group and prepare a summary/presentation for their question (coffee will be provided)
|Closing remarks
|
|
|
|
|Mike Tiemeyer
Rene Ranzinger
|
|
|-
|-
|4:00
|4:00
|60 min
|15 min presentations by each group
|Mike Tiemeyer
Raja Mazumder
|
|Karina Martinez
Rene Ranzinger
|
|
|-
| colspan="4" |Meeting adjourned. Room is available till 5pm for open discussions.
|}
|}
====='''Participant Roles'''=====
*Chair - Facilitate discussion sessions
*Chair - Facilitate discussion sessions
*Presenters - Give short ~5 minute presentation on their response to discussion question
*Presenters - Give short ~10 minute presentation as introduction to a topic
*Reporters - Take notes, prepare and present summary for discussion question
*Reporters - Take notes
*Group members - Will join chair, presenters & reporters in preparing summary for their question


=== Attendees ===
=== Attendees ===
Line 213: Line 153:
|+
|+
!
!
!Attendees
!Resource/Project
!Resource/Project
!Attendees
|-
|-
|1
|1
|GlyGen
|Michael Tiemeyer
|Karina Martinez, Rene Ranzinger, Vijay Shanker, Nathan Edwards, Mike Tiemeyer, Raja Mazumder, Jeet Vora (remote)
|University of Georgia
|-
|-
|2
|2
|Glyco@Expasy
|Rene Ranzinger
|Frederique Lisacek
|University of Georgia
|-
|-
|3
|3
|Immune Epitope Database and Analysis Project (IEDB)
|Karina Martinez
|Randi Vita
|George Washington University
|-
|-
|4
|4
|UniProt/iPTMnet/BioCreative
|Hans H. Wandall
|Cecilia Arighi
|University of Copenhagen
|-
|-
|5
|5
|GlyCosmos
|Jim Paulson
|Kiyoko F. Aoki-Kinoshita, Yasunori Yamamoto
|Scripps Institute
|-
|-
|6
|6
|IntAct
|Lance Wells
|Kalpana Panneerselvam
|University of Georgia
|-
|-
|7
|7
|MGI
|Rick Cummings
|Susan Bello (remote)
|Harvard Medical School
|-
|-
|8
|8
|UniProt
|Ten Feizi
|Maria Martin
|Imperial College London
|-
|-
|9
|9
|Microarray curation
|Kelley Moremen
|Ten Feizi, Yan Liu, Yukie Akune
|University of Georgia
|-
|-
|10
|10
|GlycoShape-3D
|Nathan Edwards
|Callum Ives
|Georgetown University
|-
|-
|11
|11
|Glyco.me
|Kiyoko Aoki-Kinoshita
|Hiren Joshi
|Soka University
|-
|-
|12
|12
|GO/PANTHER
|Hamed Jafar-Nejad
|Paul Thomas
|Baylor College of Medicine
|-
|-
|13
|13
|Rhea
|Jeff Esko
|Kristian Axelsen, Alan Bridge (remote)
|University of California San Diego
|-
|-
|14
|14
|Glycowork
|Karin Hoffmeister
|James Urban
|Versiti Blood Research Institute
|-
|-
|15
|15
|ELIBIO Project
|Marie Hollenhorst
|Krishna Khakurel (remote)
|Harvard University
|-
|-
|16
|16
|PRIDE
|Shinobu Kitazume
|Deepti Jaiswal Kundu
|Fukushima Medical University
|-
|-
|17
|17
|GlycoEnzOnto
|Mindy Porterfield
|Ted Groth
|University of Georgia
|-
|-
|18
|18
|ChEBI
|Jennifer Kohler
|Adnan Malik
|UT Southwestern Medical Center
|-
|-
|19
|19
|University of British Columbia
|Yukie Akune
|Emily Bordeleau
|Soka University
|-
|-
|20
|20
|University of York
|Ron Schnaar
|Jon Agirre (remote)
|The Johns Hopkins School of Medicine
|-
|-
|21
|21
|Glycosciences.de/MonosaccharideDB
|Sunmyoung Lee
|Thomas Lütteke (remote)
|Soka University
|-
|-
|22
|22
|Glycan microarrays
|Jingyue Wu
|Akul Mehta (remote)
|George Washington University
|-
|-}
|23
 
|IMGT
=== Travel information ===
|Taciana Manso (remote), Sofia Kossida (remote)
'''Airport'''
|-
 
|24
Kona International Airport (KOA) is a 20-minute (19 miles) car ride from the hotel. 
|O-GlcNAcAtlas
 
|Junfeng Ma (remote)
'''Uber & Lyft'''                           
|-
 
|25
Rides from Kona International Airport range from $21–$37.
|PubChem
 
|Evan Bolton (remote)
'''Taxi'''                                        
|-
 
|26
Approx. $55-$65 (one way)
|VirtualGlycome/SNFG
 
|Sriram Neelamegham (remote)
'''Parking'''             
|}
 
Self-Parking: $39/night
 
Valet Parking: $55/night
 
=== Organization Committee ===
Dr. Mike Tiemeyer and Dr. René Ranzinger organizing and chairing the workshop. Other people that helped in planning the agenda and organizing the meeting are:
 
* Raja Mazumder ([https://www.glygen.org/ GlyGen])
* Karina Martinez ([https://www.glygen.org/ GlyGen])
* Anna Bighta ([https://ccrc.uga.edu/ Complex Carbohydrate Research Center])


=== '''Contact''' ===
=== Contact ===
For questions about registration or general inquiries, please contact:  
For questions about registration or general inquiries, please contact:  


Line 327: Line 277:


Rene Ranzinger: rene@ccrc.uga.edu
Rene Ranzinger: rene@ccrc.uga.edu
=== Acknowledgment ===
The workshop is supported by the [https://www.glygen.org/ GlyGen project] and [https://www.nigms.nih.gov/ National Institute of General Medical Sciences] under the grant # [https://reporter.nih.gov/project-details/10494610 1R24GM146616 - 01].

Latest revision as of 18:52, 4 November 2023

The second "Workshop on Glycan Function Annotation," entitled "Defining Glycan Functions" will be held on November 4th at Hilton Waikoloa Village Resort in Kona on the big island of Hawaii, just prior to the 2023 annual meeting of the Society for GlycoBiology. The workshop is organized and chaired by Dr. Michael Tiemeyer and Dr. René Ranzinger from the Complex Carbohydrate Research Center and is sponsored by the GlyGen project with the support of NIH. A select group of glycobiology experts have been invited to participate in discussions and contribute their ideas for developing a framework of terms and concepts relating glycan functions to glycan structural features, motifs, and patterns.

Workshop Goals

This workshop builds on the results of the first "Workshop on Glycan Function Annotation" which was held in Padova, Italy, May 2023 in association with this year’s annual International BioCuration meeting. The first workshop brought together interested developers and leaders of international bioinformatics platforms to discuss what kinds of glycoscience data were currently available or were desirable for sharing across platforms, leading to concrete suggestions for improving the visibility and impact of glycan, glycosylation, and glycoconjugate data.

Among the recommendations of the first workshop was a proposal that the bioinformatics community would benefit from the organization of a second workshop that could harvest input from experts in glycan functions. It was anticipated that such experts could provide useful landmarks in the rapidly expanding terrain of functional glycobiology data that could guide the development of useful knowledgebases and cross-references across datatypes. With the collaborative input of data scientists, such landmarks could subsequently be developed into a glycan function ontology, similar to “GO” annotations for gene product functions. A glycan function ontology would provide a potentially powerful framework for connecting glycoscience data to many mainstream big data resources.  

Expected deliverables from the upcoming Kona workshop include:

  1. Robust discussion and subsequent documentation that establishes some level of consensus on well-supported glycan functions.
  2. Discussion and documentation of potential hierarchical relationships between glycan functions.
  3. Discussion and documentation that connects functions to explicit glycan structures, structural motifs, features, or patterns whenever possible.
  4. Discussion and documentation that highlights where ambiguities exist in connecting glycan structures and functions.
  5. Discussion and documentation of proposals for annotating glycan functions that are independent of the carrier to which they are attached or are specific for the carrier and perhaps the site on the carrier to which they are attached (autonomous vs. non-autonomous functions).

To provide structure for the workshop, five general areas of glycan function have been chosen for framing discussions.  However, the organizers expect that the boundaries of these areas are porous; we will proceed as best we can to achieve the goals. We anticipate that a successful workshop will culminate in a shared-authorship manuscript which summarizes our deliberations for community consideration and comment.

Venue

Hilton Waikoloa Village

Queens Ballroom 4

Hilton Waikoloa Village

69-425 Waikoloa Beach Drive

Waikoloa, HI 96738

Floor plan with Queens 4 ballroom marked red.

Schedule

Time Duration Topic Chair Presenters Reporters
9:00 10 min Welcome Mike Tiemeyer

Rene Ranzinger

9:10 20 min Glycan Function Overview Mike Tiemeyer
9:30 60 min Adhesion and non-immune cell-cell interactions
  • 10 min introduction talk
  • 10 min introduction talk
  • 30 min open discussion
  • 10 min session summary
Mike Tiemeyer Lance Wells

Ten Feizi

Rene Ranzinger

Karina Martinez

10:30 15 min Morning Coffee Break (in meeting room)
10:45 60 min Modulation of immune and inflammatory responses
  • 10 min introduction talk
  • 10 min introduction talk
  • 30 min open discussion
  • 10 min session summary
Kiyoko Aoki-Kinoshita Jim Paulson

Rick Cummings

Rene Ranzinger

Nathan Edwards

11:45 50 min Lunch (Kona Promenade)
12:35 60 min Modulation of signaling and protein function
  • 10 min introduction talk
  • 10 min introduction talk
  • 30 min open discussion
  • 10 min session summary
Nathan Edwards Ron Schnaar

Karin Hoffmeister

Rene Ranzinger

Kiyoko Aoki-Kinoshita

1:35 60 min Protein folding and quality control
  • 10 min introduction talk
  • 10 min introduction talk
  • 30 min open discussion
  • 10 min session summary
Lance Wells Hamed Jafar-Nejad

Nathan Edwards

Rene Ranzinger

Mindy Porterfield

2:35 15 min Coffee Break (in meeting room)
2:50 60 min Other (structural, developmental, protection, probiotic, etc.)
  • 10 min introduction talk
  • 10 min introduction talk
  • 30 min open discussion
  • 10 min session summary
Marie Hollenhorst Hans H. Wandall

Shinobu Kitazume

Rene Ranzinger

Mike Tiemeyer

3:50 10 min Closing remarks Mike Tiemeyer

Rene Ranzinger

4:00 Meeting adjourned. Room is available till 5pm for open discussions.
  • Chair - Facilitate discussion sessions
  • Presenters - Give short ~10 minute presentation as introduction to a topic
  • Reporters - Take notes

Attendees

Travel information

Airport

Kona International Airport (KOA) is a 20-minute (19 miles) car ride from the hotel.

Uber & Lyft                           

Rides from Kona International Airport range from $21–$37.

Taxi                                        

Approx. $55-$65 (one way)

Parking             

Self-Parking: $39/night

Valet Parking: $55/night

Organization Committee

Dr. Mike Tiemeyer and Dr. René Ranzinger organizing and chairing the workshop. Other people that helped in planning the agenda and organizing the meeting are:

Contact

For questions about registration or general inquiries, please contact:

Mike Tiemeyer: mtiemeyer@ccrc.uga.edu

Rene Ranzinger: rene@ccrc.uga.edu

Acknowledgment

The workshop is supported by the GlyGen project and National Institute of General Medical Sciences under the grant # 1R24GM146616 - 01.

Attendees Resource/Project
1 Michael Tiemeyer University of Georgia
2 Rene Ranzinger University of Georgia
3 Karina Martinez George Washington University
4 Hans H. Wandall University of Copenhagen
5 Jim Paulson Scripps Institute
6 Lance Wells University of Georgia
7 Rick Cummings Harvard Medical School
8 Ten Feizi Imperial College London
9 Kelley Moremen University of Georgia
10 Nathan Edwards Georgetown University
11 Kiyoko Aoki-Kinoshita Soka University
12 Hamed Jafar-Nejad Baylor College of Medicine
13 Jeff Esko University of California San Diego
14 Karin Hoffmeister Versiti Blood Research Institute
15 Marie Hollenhorst Harvard University
16 Shinobu Kitazume Fukushima Medical University
17 Mindy Porterfield University of Georgia
18 Jennifer Kohler UT Southwestern Medical Center
19 Yukie Akune Soka University
20 Ron Schnaar The Johns Hopkins School of Medicine
21 Sunmyoung Lee Soka University
22 Jingyue Wu George Washington University